General



UAE Evidence Laws: How Hiding Facts And Misleading Investigators Can Become Criminal Offences

UAE Evidence Laws: How Hiding Facts And Misleading Investigators Can Become Criminal Offences

Hiding documents or misleading investigators can expose even those unconnected with the original crime to criminal prosecution.

Discovering that a friend or relative has been involved in a criminal incident can place someone in a difficult position. You may have witnessed part of the incident, received a message that could help establish what happened or been asked to keep a particular document out of sight. While you may have played no part in the original offence, deliberately withholding or concealing information to frustrate an investigation could expose you to criminal liability.

 

Many people assume that criminal responsibility rests solely with the person who committed the underlying offence. UAE law, however, recognises that interference with the process of uncovering the truth can constitute a separate criminal act, even where the individual concerned had no involvement in the original incident.

 

Evidence plays a fundamental role in establishing the facts, identifying those responsible and enabling judicial authorities to determine criminal liability. Destroying records, hiding relevant material or knowingly giving investigators misleading information can consequently have serious legal implications. An attempt to protect another person may create a separate legal problem for the individual providing that protection.

 

When Interference With an Investigation Becomes an Offence

 

Federal Decree-Law No. 31 of 2021 on the Crimes and Penalties Law contains provisions addressing attempts to obstruct investigations and interfere with judicial proceedings.

 

Article 315 deals with conduct intended to mislead judicial or investigation authorities, including those responsible for gathering evidence. It provides for incarceration where a person deliberately alters circumstances relating to individuals, places or objects, conceals evidence of a crime or knowingly provides false information with the intention of misleading the competent authorities.

 

The provision is not confined to physically removing or destroying evidence. Manipulating the circumstances surrounding an incident or deliberately giving investigators an inaccurate account may also bring a person's conduct under scrutiny.

 

Consider someone who witnesses an assault and subsequently removes objects from the scene to create a false impression of what happened. Although that individual may not have participated in the assault, deliberately changing the circumstances to mislead investigators could give rise to criminal liability under Article 315, provided the necessary legal elements are established.

 

The distinction is important. Remaining silent and actively interfering with an investigation are not necessarily the same thing. The intention behind the conduct, particularly whether it was designed to mislead the authorities, is central to determining whether the provision applies.

 

Hiding or Destroying Documents Can Attract Separate Penalties

 

Article 316 addresses the concealment, destruction or appropriation of documents, deeds and other items connected with an investigation or judicial proceedings, where the conduct is intended to mislead the judiciary or investigation authorities. The provision prescribes incarceration and a fine.

 

Its scope also extends to circumstances in which relevant material has not yet been physically handed over to the authorities. It covers situations where a document or item remains with the person who originally submitted it, pending a request for its production.

 

This has particular significance for businesses and individuals who hold records that could become relevant to an investigation or court proceedings. Retaining possession of a document does not necessarily place someone beyond the reach of the law if it is deliberately concealed or destroyed for an unlawful purpose.

 

For example, a company may become the subject of a commercial investigation involving financial transactions. If an employee deliberately destroys or hides accounting records to prevent investigators from establishing the nature of those transactions, Article 316 may become relevant.

 

The legal concern extends beyond the disappearance of the material itself. What matters is whether someone deliberately interfered with documents or other items connected with judicial or investigative proceedings to compromise the authorities' ability to establish the facts.

 

The Legal Obligation to Produce Evidence

 

A separate issue arises when a person fails to produce material that could assist a court in establishing a fact. Article 317 addresses situations in which an individual is legally required to produce a document or another object but fails to comply.

 

The provision prescribes incarceration for a period not exceeding six months or a fine not exceeding Dh5,000, except where the failure to produce the material is permitted by law.

 

There is an important distinction between this provision and the preceding articles. Article 317 does not create a general obligation for everyone to volunteer documents or disclose every piece of information in their possession. It concerns a failure to comply with an existing legal obligation to produce relevant material, subject to the exceptions recognised by law.

 

This distinction is significant because the administration of justice must operate alongside the legal rights of individuals. A person who does not voluntarily disclose information cannot automatically be treated in the same way as someone who disregards a legally enforceable requirement to produce evidence.

 

Digital Records Present New Challenges

 

The growing reliance on electronic communications and digital platforms has changed the nature of evidence in criminal investigations. Messages exchanged through applications, emails, CCTV recordings, electronic transaction histories and other digital records can all help investigators reconstruct events and establish the sequence of transactions or communications.

 

Deleting messages after learning that they may be examined as part of an investigation, or removing CCTV footage to prevent authorities from determining what happened at a particular location, could raise questions about deliberate interference with evidence.

 

Nevertheless, deleting electronic information does not automatically amount to a criminal offence. Investigators and courts must consider the circumstances surrounding its removal, the individual's knowledge, the purpose of the action and whether the relevant statutory requirements have been satisfied.

 

Where the necessary elements are established, the deliberate concealment or destruction of electronic material may raise issues under the provisions dealing with interference with evidence. Information does not become legally insignificant simply because it is stored on a mobile telephone, computer or online platform rather than in a physical document.

 

For individuals and companies, the practical lesson is that electronic records deserve the same attention as paper documents. Once an investigation or legal dispute is anticipated, potentially relevant digital information should be preserved rather than deleted, altered or otherwise compromised.

 

Can Loyalty to a Friend or Relative Provide a Defence?

 

Some of the more complicated situations arise when individuals conceal information to protect someone close to them. A family member may hide an object to shield a relative, an employee may remove company records following instructions from a senior colleague, or a friend may give investigators an inaccurate account in the hope of helping an accused person avoid prosecution.

 

Although the motivations may differ, personal loyalty, fear or pressure does not automatically eliminate the possibility of criminal liability.

 

The Crimes and Penalties Law also contains provisions dealing with assistance given to offenders. Article 337, for instance, addresses knowingly helping an offender evade justice through conduct that includes concealing evidence, providing false information or otherwise assisting the person, subject to the circumstances and penalties prescribed by law.

 

However, the existence of a personal relationship with an accused individual does not, by itself, establish criminal responsibility. Nor does simply knowing that an offence has occurred or choosing not to volunteer information automatically amount to an offence.

 

The authorities must examine the individual's actual conduct, knowledge and intention, together with the statutory requirements and any applicable exceptions. The legal position depends on what the person did and the circumstances in which the assistance was provided, rather than merely their relationship with the accused.

 

Why Intention and Circumstances Matter

 

A critical factor in assessing liability under these provisions is the difference between deliberate interference with evidence and an innocent failure to preserve or produce information.

 

A document may be misplaced during routine business operations. CCTV footage may be deleted accidentally, or an individual may be unable to produce a particular item because it is no longer in their possession. Such situations cannot automatically be equated with deliberately destroying or concealing evidence to mislead investigators.

 

Articles 315 and 316 specifically address conduct involving an intention or purpose to mislead the relevant authorities. Article 317, meanwhile, concerns non-compliance with a legal obligation to produce material that may help establish a fact before a court, subject to the statutory exceptions.

 

Consequently, the mere fact that evidence is unavailable does not establish that a criminal offence has occurred. The nature of the conduct, the circumstances surrounding it and the applicable legal requirements must all be examined before responsibility can be determined.

 

This distinction is an important safeguard against treating genuine mistakes, accidental loss or an inability to produce information as deliberate attempts to obstruct justice.

 

Preserving Evidence is Part of Legal Compliance

 

The UAE's approach to evidence concealment reflects a fundamental principle of criminal justice: accountability depends not only on identifying those who commit offences but also on protecting the integrity of the investigations and judicial proceedings through which responsibility is established.

 

Individuals should avoid destroying, altering, hiding or manipulating material that could be relevant to an investigation, whether their intention is to protect themselves or someone else. Where a competent authority requests documents or information, it is equally important to understand the nature of the legal obligation and seek appropriate legal advice before taking action.

 

Businesses have comparable responsibilities. Maintaining accurate records, implementing effective document-retention policies and ensuring that potentially relevant electronic information is preserved when disputes or investigations arise can help minimise legal exposure. Employees should also exercise caution when instructed to remove, modify or dispose of records that may have evidential significance.

 

Conclusion

 

Silence alone does not necessarily constitute a criminal offence under UAE law. Equally, every failure to disclose information or produce a document does not automatically result in criminal liability. The legal position changes when a person deliberately conceals, destroys or manipulates evidence with the intention of misleading investigators or interfering with judicial proceedings.

 

Such conduct can expose an individual to a separate criminal investigation, even if that person had no involvement in the original offence. The consequences may extend far beyond the incident they initially sought to keep hidden.

 

Protecting someone from accountability can itself become a criminal matter. In the UAE, an attempt to conceal the truth may ultimately place the person responsible for hiding it under investigation.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

Dubai Court Upholds Businessman’s Acquittal In Alleged Detention Case

Dubai Court Upholds Businessman’s Acquittal In Alleged Detention Case

Disputed witness accounts and telephone records led the court to find insufficient grounds to overturn the acquittal.

The Dubai Court of Appeal has upheld the acquittal of a businessman accused of detaining a woman in his Business Bay apartment for around six hours and allegedly using force and threats to compel her to engage in sexual activity.

 

The court dismissed the Public Prosecution’s appeal, finding insufficient evidence to overturn the Court of First Instance’s verdict. The businessman had faced charges of unlawfully depriving the woman of her freedom through force and threats for a sexual purpose under the UAE Crimes and Penalties Law.

 

According to prosecution records, the woman told investigators that she had met the businessman near a nightclub and accepted his invitation to visit his apartment for drinks. She alleged that he pressured her to consume alcohol and refused to let her leave when she asked to go.

 

She further claimed that he raised a shoe towards her face in a threatening manner, grabbed her and pushed her onto a sofa in the bedroom. When she attempted to contact a friend, he allegedly took her phone temporarily.

 

The woman said she eventually managed to message her friend and share her live location when a delivery driver arrived. Her friend subsequently went to the building seeking assistance, leading to police intervention.

 

The businessman denied the allegations, maintaining that the woman had visited voluntarily and that he had neither restrained nor assaulted her.

 

Security Guard’s Testimony

 

A building security guard told the court that the woman had entered the premises voluntarily and that her visitor details had been recorded in the reception system.

 

The guard said he accompanied police officers to the apartment, where the businessman opened the door. He found the woman standing in the living room holding her phone. She appeared normal and began crying only after officers spoke to her, according to his testimony.

 

The Court of First Instance considered the guard’s account alongside the building records when assessing whether unlawful confinement had been established. It questioned whether the allegation of a six-hour detention was consistent with the guard’s description of finding the woman standing with her phone.

 

The arresting officer testified that the businessman initially denied having a woman inside the apartment, but police subsequently found her there. The officer also said the businessman had referred to a financial disagreement.

 

Another officer, who had not attended the scene, told the court that he had recorded the woman’s statement at the police station. As she spoke in her native language, her friend translated her account into English.

 

The Court of First Instance disregarded statements attributed to the businessman in an initial police report because he had been questioned without the assistance of a sworn interpreter.

 

The defence also argued that the complainant and her friend had not appeared for cross-examination, leaving their accounts untested under oath.

 

Phone Records and Messages Form Part of defence

 

The defence examined the case file, reconstructed the sequence of events and analysed telephone records and WhatsApp messages.

 

It argued that the communications demonstrated prior contact and arrangements involving the businessman and another woman, whom the defence alleged had helped shape the accusation. According to its account, this woman had arranged for the complainant to meet the businessman voluntarily, contradicting the allegation that he had lured or detained her.

 

The defence also relied on a telephone call between the businessman and his wife that allegedly lasted more than an hour during the period in which the complainant claimed she was being detained and threatened. It argued that the call raised questions about the complainant’s version of events.

 

Images of the apartment entrance were also presented to show that the door could be opened from inside without a key. The defence maintained that the woman had retained her smartphone and could communicate, with no apparent obstacle preventing her from leaving or seeking assistance. Defence witnesses also supported its position.

 

The defence further highlighted discrepancies between the prosecution witnesses’ courtroom testimony and their earlier statements to the Public Prosecution.

 

Appeal Court Finds No Grounds to Interfere

 

The Court of First Instance acquitted the businessman, concluding that the evidence was insufficient to establish the alleged offences, particularly the required criminal intent.

 

The Public Prosecution challenged the acquittal, but the Court of Appeal found no sufficient legal or evidential grounds to disturb the lower court’s findings. It accordingly rejected the appeal and upheld the businessman’s acquittal.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

US Federal Judge Extends Order Blocking Donald Trump’s Triumphal Arch Project

US Federal Judge Extends Order Blocking Donald Trump’s Triumphal Arch Project

The two-week extension gives the court more time to consider a request to halt construction of the proposed 250-foot monument.

A federal judge on Wednesday extended an earlier ruling blocking President Donald Trump’s administration from constructing a proposed 250-foot arch near Arlington National Cemetery, marking another setback for one of his efforts to leave a lasting architectural mark on the US capital.

 

In a brief order, US District Judge Tanya Chutkan extended by another two weeks a restraining order she issued on November 5, which temporarily halted construction of the arch. The original order was due to expire on Thursday.

 

Chutkan said the extension would give her more time to consider a request by the plaintiffs, including Virginia and the District of Columbia, for a longer-term injunction to stop the project.

 

White House spokesman Davis Ingle criticised the ruling. "We will continue making the case for this beautiful and fitting monument and are confident we will be fully vindicated as this litigation proceeds," Ingle said.

 

Chutkan’s rulings have highlighted growing judicial scrutiny of construction projects undertaken by Trump in Washington during his second term. These include plans for a White House ballroom, renovations to the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool and a proposed championship-level golf course about two miles from the White House.

 

On November 14, another federal judge in Washington ordered that a riverside park remain open for the time being rather than close to make way for the golf course project. The Trump administration appealed against that decision on Wednesday.

 

Historic preservation groups and other plaintiffs are challenging several of Trump’s projects, arguing that they bypassed federal reviews, lack congressional authorisation and threaten public spaces.

 

The proposed 250-foot (76-metre) arch, depicted in a design rendering with a flame held by a 60-foot gold winged female figure and flanked by golden flying eagles, would be located near the Potomac River, between Arlington National Cemetery and the Lincoln Memorial.

 

The Trump administration argues that Congress authorised the arch more than a century ago, when it approved the construction of a bridge across the Potomac River. It has said the monument would honour veterans.

 

In September, Trump described the project on social media as a "top grade Military Complex/Triumphal Arch", saying it would "house, store, and have the rapid ability to use large numbers of drones, plus Snipers, on both the roof and plaza areas".

 

Nine members of the Kennedy political dynasty are also seeking to block the project, arguing that it would obstruct views and cast shadows over the graves of their relatives.

 

Several Democrats in Congress have vowed to prevent construction once they take control in January, following their victory in November’s midterm elections.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

Oman Introduces New Security Rules For Public And Private Facilities

Oman Introduces New Security Rules For Public And Private Facilities

New law mandates approved surveillance systems, security plans and compliance measures, with fines of up to RO20,000 for violations.

Government bodies and private-sector establishments across Oman will have to install approved surveillance and early-warning systems, draw up security protection plans and comply with new safety standards under legislation introducing penalties of up to RO20,000 for violations.

 

Royal Decree No 100/2026, issued by His Majesty Sultan Haitham bin Tarik promulgates the Law on the Protection of Facilities and assigns the Royal Oman Police (ROP) responsibility for supervising its implementation and enforcing compliance.

 

Published in the Official Gazette on November 1, the law will take effect six months after publication. Establishments falling within its scope will be given two years from the commencement date to bring their operations into compliance.

 

The legislation covers government establishments, public corporate entities and private-sector facilities, including power stations, telecommunications stations and commercial shops. Other facilities may also be brought within its scope through a decision by the Inspector General of Police and Customs, subject to approval from the National Security Council.

 

Royal establishments and facilities operated by military and security agencies are excluded from the law.

 

Security Plans and Surveillance Systems

 

Establishments covered by the legislation must prepare comprehensive security protection plans through licensed security consultancy offices. These plans must receive approval from the competent authority before they are implemented.

 

The plans are required to set out internal and external security arrangements, emergency response procedures, business continuity measures and the protection systems needed to safeguard each facility.

 

Mandatory security equipment includes surveillance cameras, intrusion detection systems and early-warning devices. Establishments must ensure that these systems remain operational, are regularly updated and are connected to the systems of the competent authority in accordance with prescribed procedures.

 

The law also requires facilities to retain recordings generated by their security systems for periods to be determined under the executive regulations. They must provide surveillance footage and other relevant information when requested by the competent authority and display notices informing visitors that the premises are monitored by cameras.

 

Security consultancy offices will be required to obtain licences before offering facility protection services. Private-sector establishments must also demonstrate that they meet the prescribed security standards when applying for or renewing their operating licences.

 

Public establishments must assign an administrative division to supervise compliance with the law, while private-sector facilities must appoint a designated person to take responsibility for implementing the security requirements. The competent authority may also direct establishments to conduct security exercises to assess the effectiveness of their protective arrangements.

 

Penalties for Violations

 

The legislation sets out criminal penalties for employees who fail to discharge their prescribed security responsibilities. Such violations carry imprisonment ranging from 10 days to three months and fines of RO500 to RO2,000, or either of the two penalties.

 

More serious offences include deliberately refusing to implement security requirements, concealing information about potential threats, disclosing confidential security documents and abusing official powers. Those found guilty face imprisonment of three months to three years and fines ranging from RO1,000 to RO3,000.

 

The penalties become considerably more severe when such offences are committed during emergencies, war or natural disasters. In these circumstances, offenders face imprisonment of three to 10 years and fines of RO3,000 to RO10,000.

 

The law also provides for administrative sanctions, including fines of up to RO20,000. The executive regulations will specify the applicable administrative penalties and the procedures governing their enforcement.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

Capital Hotel Brawl: Sentences Reduced For Eight Defendants After Reconciliation

Capital Hotel Brawl: Sentences Reduced For Eight Defendants After Reconciliation

Court halves fines to Dh150,000 each following an amicable settlement and the victim’s appeal for the defendants’ release.

Eight defendants convicted in connection with a brawl at a hotel in Abu Dhabi have had their sentences reduced following reconciliation between the parties and an appeal by the victim seeking their release.

 

The Abu Dhabi court revised the sentences, reducing the fines from Dh300,000 to Dh150,000 for each defendant.

 

The court took into account the reconciliation and withdrawal of claims between the parties, as well as the victim’s appeal to the Abu Dhabi Government requesting the release of the convicted individuals.

 

The sentence reductions followed an amicable settlement, with the victim expressing a desire for the defendants to be released, according to the Abu Dhabi Judicial Department.

 

On Friday, November 13, the Abu Dhabi Criminal Court convicted 10 defendants following a group brawl inside a hotel. Six were sentenced to six months in prison, fined Dh300,000 each and ordered to be deported after serving their sentences. They were convicted of disturbing public security, causing panic and endangering lives.

 

Two other defendants were sentenced to six months in prison, fined Dh300,000 each and ordered to be deported for violating privacy laws by using information technology to film and publish footage of the incident.

 

The arrests followed the circulation of a video on social media showing UFC fighter Merab Dvalishvili and Usman Nurmagomedov involved in a brawl. However, Abu Dhabi authorities have not directly linked the hotel incident to the two fighters.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

Trump’s $10 Billion BBC Defamation Suit Cleared To Proceed By US Judge

Trump’s $10 Billion BBC Defamation Suit Cleared To Proceed By US Judge

Court allows Trump’s claim over an edited speech to move forward but dismisses his unfair trade practices allegation.

A federal judge has ruled that US President Donald Trump’s $10 billion defamation lawsuit against the BBC over a misleadingly edited clip of a speech can proceed, but dismissed his claim of unfair trade practices against the broadcaster.

 

Trump is suing Britain’s publicly funded broadcaster for at least $10 billion over edited clips of a speech that made it appear he had directed supporters to storm the US Capitol on January 6, 2021. The case is one of several lawsuits Trump has filed against news organisations as part of a wider campaign to challenge media coverage he dislikes.

 

US District Judge Jeffrey Kuntz in Florida declined to dismiss Trump’s defamation claim, ruling that he had plausibly alleged that the broadcaster had damaged his reputation and knew, or should have known, that the edited clip was misleading. However, the ruling did not determine whether Trump had established those allegations.

 

Trump described the decision as a “huge victory” in a social media post. “We will continue fighting against, and defeating, all of those who try to deceive the American People!” he wrote.

 

A BBC spokesperson said the broadcaster was surprised by the decision but respected the court’s authority and remained confident in its position.

 

The BBC has previously acknowledged that the edits were misleading and apologised to Trump, although it denies being legally liable for defamation.

 

Trump’s lawsuit, filed in December in a Florida federal court, accuses the BBC of defaming him by splicing together separate sections of his speech. These included a passage in which he told supporters to march on the Capitol and another in which he urged them to “fight like hell”. The edited version omitted a section in which he called for peaceful protest.

 

The speech was featured in a BBC Panorama documentary shortly before the 2024 presidential election, which Trump won. A leaked internal BBC memo subsequently cited the edits as evidence of potential political bias, triggering a public relations crisis for the broadcaster and leading to several high-level resignations.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

Sheikh Mohammed Issues New Law Defining Dubai Municipality’s Powers

Sheikh Mohammed Issues New Law Defining Dubai Municipality’s Powers

Law sets out the Municipality’s mandate to advance urban planning, expand green spaces and improve quality of life.

Dubai Ruler His Highness Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, Vice President and Prime Minister of the UAE, has issued Law No. 18 of 2026 concerning Dubai Municipality, defining its objectives, responsibilities and powers to support sustainable development, improve quality of life and strengthen the emirate’s global competitiveness.

 

The Law applies to Dubai Municipality, established under the 1961 Order Establishing the Dubai Municipality Council, as a government department with legal personality and the capacity to undertake all activities and transactions necessary to achieve its objectives.

 

Under the new legislation, the Municipality will exercise its powers and responsibilities throughout the Emirate of Dubai, including special development zones and free zones such as the Dubai International Financial Centre (DIFC). However, its jurisdiction will remain subject to the provisions of the Law, related decisions and other applicable legislation, unless a specific legislative provision exempts a particular zone.

 

The Law sets out a broad range of objectives for Dubai Municipality, with a focus on developing a future-ready city that promotes quality of life, happiness and wellbeing. These objectives will be pursued through an integrated and sustainable urban planning system that supports economic growth, protects Dubai’s urban heritage and responds to the needs of future cities.

 

Another key priority is enhancing the urban environment through the development of world-class public and recreational facilities and the expansion of green spaces across the emirate. These initiatives are intended to create a more sustainable and liveable city while improving the overall wellbeing of residents and visitors.

 

The Municipality will also be responsible for developing infrastructure and advancing integrated waste management systems to support sustainable development and ensure the efficient use of resources. The legislation further seeks to strengthen the building and construction sector through the adoption of advanced global technologies, while maintaining high standards of public health, safety and food safety in line with international best practices.

 

The Law also emphasises stronger private-sector partnerships and the creation of new economic opportunities. It seeks to promote proactive, integrated municipal services that respond to community expectations and contribute to improved living standards. Building strategic relationships with government entities, cities and comparable institutions worldwide is another stated objective.

 

In addition to defining the Municipality’s mandate and powers, the legislation grants it oversight and inspection responsibilities, including the authority to verify compliance with applicable laws and regulations.

 

Subject to existing legislation, Dubai Municipality may outsource any of its functions or powers to public or private entities through formal agreements. Such agreements must specify the respective rights and obligations of the Municipality and the contracted entity, together with the conditions, requirements and standards governing the outsourced activities.

 

The Law also establishes the framework for Dubai Municipality’s executive structure, comprising the Director General, executive directors and administrative and technical employees.

 

It sets out the procedures for appointing the Director General and defines the office-holder’s responsibilities and powers. The Director General will be appointed through a decree issued by the Ruler of Dubai and will be directly accountable to the Executive Council of Dubai for carrying out the duties assigned under the legislation.

 

The new legislation further specifies the Municipality’s financial resources and establishes rules governing its accounts and financial year in accordance with government accounting principles, standards and practices.

 

It also places a duty on individuals and government entities to cooperate fully with Dubai Municipality and its affiliated entities. They must meet the Municipality’s requirements and provide any data, information, documents, statistics and reports considered necessary for carrying out its functions and achieving its objectives under the Law, related decisions and applicable Dubai legislation.

 

Law No. 18 of 2026 replaces the 1961 Order Establishing the Dubai Municipality Council. Any provisions in other legislation that conflict with the new Law will stand repealed to the extent of the inconsistency.

 

Existing legislation, regulations, local orders, decisions and bylaws governing Dubai Municipality, including those issued under the 1961 Order, will remain in force provided they do not conflict with the new Law or other applicable legislation in Dubai. They will continue to apply until replaced by new legislation, regulations, decisions or bylaws.

 

The Law will be published in the Official Gazette and will come into force on the date of its publication.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

Dubai Appeal Court Upholds Jail Term And Deportation In Child Assault Case

Dubai Appeal Court Upholds Jail Term And Deportation In Child Assault Case

The court finds witness statements and forensic evidence sufficient to uphold the conviction and reject the appeal.

The Dubai Court of Appeal has upheld a one-year prison sentence and deportation order against a man convicted of sexually assaulting a 13-year-old girl, finding that the evidence was sufficient to establish his guilt.

 

The court accepted the appeal on procedural grounds but rejected the substantive arguments, leaving the original conviction and sentence unchanged.

 

The defendant was found guilty of exploiting the girl's young age by lying beside her on a bed under the same blanket, placing his head on her chest and putting his arm around her shoulder. The incident was investigated by Al Qusais Police Station.

 

The Public Prosecution charged the man under Articles 126(1) and 407(1–3) of Federal Decree-Law No. 31 of 2021 on Crimes and Penalties, as amended by Federal Decree-Law No. 36 of 2022.

 

Defence challenges conviction

 

The court of first instance sentenced the defendant to one year in prison, followed by deportation from the UAE. It also referred the civil claim to the competent civil court for separate consideration.

 

During a closed appeal hearing, the defendant denied the charges. His lawyer sought an acquittal, arguing that the evidence was insufficient to establish the elements of the offence or demonstrate criminal intent.

 

Alternatively, the defence requested a reduction in the sentence. The Public Prosecution opposed the appeal and urged the court to uphold the original judgment.

 

Court finds evidence sufficient

 

After examining the case file, the appeal court concluded that the lower court had properly evaluated the evidence and reached its decision on sound legal grounds.

 

The evidence included statements made by the defendant during Public Prosecution investigations, accounts provided by the girl's parents to investigators and forensic reports issued by the General Department of Forensic Science and Criminology.

 

The judges found that the evidence, considered collectively, was sufficient to establish the offence and sustain the conviction. They rejected the defence's arguments concerning the absence of the essential elements of the crime, noting that these issues had already been examined by the court of first instance.

 

The appeal court found no errors in the lower court's assessment of the evidence or its legal reasoning. It also observed that the defence had produced no new evidence or legal grounds warranting an acquittal or a reduction in the sentence. The judges accordingly adopted the reasoning of the original judgment.

 

The one-year prison term and deportation order remain in force, with deportation to take place after the sentence has been served. The civil claim will be considered separately by the competent civil court.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

LuLu Group Rules Out Withdrawal Of Defamation Cases Despite Apologies

LuLu Group Rules Out Withdrawal Of Defamation Cases Despite Apologies

The group will pursue legal action over alleged false claims against the company and its chairman.

LuLu Group has ruled out withdrawing defamation cases filed against individuals accused of circulating false allegations about the company and its chairman, M.A. Yusuff Ali, saying public apologies from those involved will not affect its legal position.

 

Nandakumar, Director of Global Marketing and Communications at LuLu Group, told Khaleej Times that the company has full confidence in the Indian judicial system and will pursue all available legal remedies.

 

"This is not about silencing criticism. It is about protecting the truth," Nandakumar said.

 

Legal Action Across Three States

 

The group has initiated legal proceedings in courts across Kerala, Lucknow and Delhi against individuals it accuses of spreading fake news and malicious allegations. Nandakumar said the company would neither retreat from its position nor withdraw the cases.

 

The legal action follows a defamation suit filed by Yusuff Ali seeking Rs100 million (approximately Dh4 million) in damages for reputational harm.

 

The Delhi High Court had earlier directed the editor of an online Malayalam news portal to remove allegedly defamatory material concerning the LuLu chairman. It also restrained the individual from making further comments about Yusuff Ali on any platform. A separate defamation case was filed before the Ernakulam Sub Court in Kerala.

 

The individual concerned issued a public apology in late October, admitting that his remarks were incorrect and withdrawing the allegations. The comments were connected to a gold smuggling case and had appeared in a video published in November 2020.

 

Nandakumar told Khaleej Times that the apology was a personal matter for the individual and would not alter the group's decision to continue with the legal proceedings. He also ruled out any out-of-court settlement.

 

He questioned claims surrounding the recording of an apology and reiterated that the company would pursue the matter through the courts.

 

"We will not allow even a grain of false allegation against the brand or the chairman," he said.

 

Nandakumar also criticised the role of social media engagement, saying likes, clicks and shares were driving the circulation of allegations and misinformation.

 

'Not Just a Business'

 

Emphasising the organisation's wider responsibilities, Nandakumar said LuLu was more than a commercial enterprise, describing it as a home for more than 75,000 employees.

 

The group had built its reputation over several decades through trust, integrity and hard work, he said, adding that these values remained central to its identity.

 

He said the company welcomed fair criticism and differing opinions but would not allow deliberate falsehoods or malicious attacks on its reputation to go unchallenged.

 

The group also reiterated its respect for freedom of speech and the public's right to express opinions, question decisions and criticise its activities. However, it distinguished legitimate criticism from the deliberate circulation of fake news, false allegations and misinformation intended to damage its reputation.

 

"We have zero tolerance for any such attempts to malign the reputation of LuLu, our organisation or our Chairman," Nandakumar said.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.