WORLD



Nvidia Insurance Shields Its Board But Leaves Company Exposed To Lawsuits

Nvidia Insurance Shields Its Board But Leaves Company Exposed To Lawsuits

Nvidia has $950 million in cover for directors but no insurance against securities claims targeting the company.

Nvidia has insurance to protect its directors and senior executives against securities lawsuits, but the company itself has no equivalent cover. This means it could be forced to draw on its cash reserves if litigation arising from the abrupt departure of Jensen Huang as chief executive proves successful.

 

The Insurer, a publication owned by Reuters, reported last Saturday that Nvidia has up to $950 million in insurance coverage for its directors and officers. However, the company does not have the type of insurance that would typically cover a company's legal defence costs, settlements and judgments in securities litigation.

 

The distinction could prove significant. If Nvidia's directors or officers are held personally liable for failing to exercise proper oversight of the company, the insurance could cover eligible settlements or judgments that Nvidia is unable to indemnify, helping to protect their personal wealth.

 

However, any successful securities fraud claims brought directly against Nvidia over its falling share price would have to be paid by the company itself. Nvidia has more than $50 billion in cash reserves.

 

Huang resigned as Nvidia CEO on Thursday, four days after issuing a statement saying he had been unfaithful to his wife. Reports have linked him to an intimate relationship with Alice Huang, a former senior executive of Megaspeed International, an Nvidia customer that is under US investigation over suspected espionage on behalf of China. Alice Huang and Jensen Huang are not related.

 

Megaspeed has been under US scrutiny over allegations that it may have diverted some Nvidia chips to China, potentially in violation of US export restrictions.

 

On Tuesday, Huang said he deeply regretted the problems he had caused the Nvidia board and would be honoured to return to the company. However, sources told Reuters that the board was not considering his reinstatement.

 

Companies such as Nvidia generally indemnify their directors and officers against legal claims arising from their corporate duties. However, Delaware corporate law prohibits companies from indemnifying directors and officers against certain categories of liability, creating a role for insurance to cover exposures that cannot be met by the company.

 

Nvidia is unusual because, unlike the vast majority of publicly listed US companies, it has no insurance covering securities fraud claims against the company itself.

 

Two insurance experts said Nvidia's substantial financial resources could explain why it chose not to purchase cover for its own corporate liabilities.

 

"With a balance sheet larger than that of many insurance companies, it's reasonable to conclude Nvidia did not see value in the options offered to it by the marketplace to transfer this risk," said Rik Goyton, executive vice president and financial lines practice leader at CAC, part of The Baldwin Group, an insurance and risk management firm.

 

Nvidia, which is due to report its results after the market closes on Tuesday, did not respond to a request for comment.

 

Lawsuits Filed

 

At least two lawsuits have been filed since November 8, when Huang disclosed that he had been unfaithful to his wife.

 

The first is a proposed class action alleging securities fraud, filed by an individual shareholder in federal court in San Francisco against Nvidia and Huang. The complaint claims investors were misled about the company's relationship with Megaspeed and Huang's relationship with Alice Huang.

 

To succeed in a securities fraud claim, plaintiffs must establish that Nvidia and Huang knowingly misled investors, that investors relied on the alleged misrepresentations and that those statements artificially inflated the company's share price.

 

The proposed class period includes a 20% decline in Nvidia's share price, representing approximately $1 trillion in lost market value. There is no straightforward formula for calculating damages in securities fraud cases, although the proportion of losses recovered generally tends to decrease as the overall losses increase.

 

The largest securities class action settlement on record is $7.2 billion, reached in 2006 between investors in the collapsed energy trading company Enron and several banks and other defendants, according to Stanford Law School's Securities Class Action Clearinghouse.

 

Although Nvidia has no insurance against securities claims brought directly against it, Huang could potentially rely on the directors' and officers' policy to cover eligible personal liabilities that the company does not indemnify.

 

"Huang's personal exposure on the 10b-5 (securities fraud) claims is theoretically much larger than $950 million given the massive destruction of value as measured by market cap, but plaintiffs would presumably seek to recover from the company first," said Joel Fleming, a lawyer who represents shareholders.

 

The $950 million insurance policy could be more significant in the second case, a derivative lawsuit filed against Nvidia's directors in federal court in San Jose, California.

 

The complaint alleges that the directors failed to exercise proper oversight of the company and disregarded concerns about Megaspeed. It also claims the board waited too long to investigate Huang's relationship with Alice Huang.

 

On Friday, Reuters exclusively reported that Huang had misled several senior company executives, including general counsel Tim Teter, about the nature of his relationship with Alice Huang. The report was based on information from two people familiar with the matter and internal correspondence reviewed by Reuters.

 

Legal experts said that if Huang had misled investors, it could strengthen the case brought by shareholders in the securities class action.

 

Both Huang and Teter have agreed to appear for recorded interviews with several US House committees in early December.

 

However, if the board removed Huang after discovering that he had misled senior company executives, that decision could help protect the directors against claims in the derivative lawsuit. It could demonstrate that they had taken action once the alleged misconduct came to light.

 

Derivative lawsuits seek to recover losses suffered by a company as a result of alleged failures by its directors. In Nvidia's case, the potential losses could include any settlement arising from the securities class action, as well as fines or other financial penalties.

 

Unlike securities class action settlements, which compensate investors, any recovery in a derivative action is paid to the company itself rather than directly to shareholders.

 

Settlements in derivative cases are almost always funded through insurance. However, there have been rare instances in which directors have had to contribute from their personal wealth, including members of Tesla's board.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

US Federal Judge Extends Order Blocking Donald Trump’s Triumphal Arch Project

US Federal Judge Extends Order Blocking Donald Trump’s Triumphal Arch Project

The two-week extension gives the court more time to consider a request to halt construction of the proposed 250-foot monument.

A federal judge on Wednesday extended an earlier ruling blocking President Donald Trump’s administration from constructing a proposed 250-foot arch near Arlington National Cemetery, marking another setback for one of his efforts to leave a lasting architectural mark on the US capital.

 

In a brief order, US District Judge Tanya Chutkan extended by another two weeks a restraining order she issued on November 5, which temporarily halted construction of the arch. The original order was due to expire on Thursday.

 

Chutkan said the extension would give her more time to consider a request by the plaintiffs, including Virginia and the District of Columbia, for a longer-term injunction to stop the project.

 

White House spokesman Davis Ingle criticised the ruling. "We will continue making the case for this beautiful and fitting monument and are confident we will be fully vindicated as this litigation proceeds," Ingle said.

 

Chutkan’s rulings have highlighted growing judicial scrutiny of construction projects undertaken by Trump in Washington during his second term. These include plans for a White House ballroom, renovations to the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool and a proposed championship-level golf course about two miles from the White House.

 

On November 14, another federal judge in Washington ordered that a riverside park remain open for the time being rather than close to make way for the golf course project. The Trump administration appealed against that decision on Wednesday.

 

Historic preservation groups and other plaintiffs are challenging several of Trump’s projects, arguing that they bypassed federal reviews, lack congressional authorisation and threaten public spaces.

 

The proposed 250-foot (76-metre) arch, depicted in a design rendering with a flame held by a 60-foot gold winged female figure and flanked by golden flying eagles, would be located near the Potomac River, between Arlington National Cemetery and the Lincoln Memorial.

 

The Trump administration argues that Congress authorised the arch more than a century ago, when it approved the construction of a bridge across the Potomac River. It has said the monument would honour veterans.

 

In September, Trump described the project on social media as a "top grade Military Complex/Triumphal Arch", saying it would "house, store, and have the rapid ability to use large numbers of drones, plus Snipers, on both the roof and plaza areas".

 

Nine members of the Kennedy political dynasty are also seeking to block the project, arguing that it would obstruct views and cast shadows over the graves of their relatives.

 

Several Democrats in Congress have vowed to prevent construction once they take control in January, following their victory in November’s midterm elections.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

US Judiciary Workplace Complaints: Supreme Court Declines To Hear Challenge

US Judiciary Workplace Complaints: Supreme Court Declines To Hear Challenge

Justices reject appeal by former public defender alleging sexual harassment by her supervisor.

The US Supreme Court declined to hear a case challenging how the federal judiciary handles complaints of employee misconduct, rejecting an appeal by a former federal public defender who alleged that she had been sexually harassed by her supervisor.

 

The justices declined to hear Caryn Strickland’s appeal against a lower court ruling that found she had failed to establish violations of her Fifth Amendment rights under the US Constitution, including equal protection under the law and due process.

 

Her case had been the subject of a rare trial examining how the judiciary handles workplace misconduct complaints involving its 30,000 employees. Unlike other federal government workers, judicial employees are not covered by statutory protections against discrimination.

 

In a petition urging the Supreme Court to take up the case, Strickland’s lawyer, Emory University law professor Paul Koster, argued that it offered the justices an opportunity to clarify the federal judiciary’s responsibility to ensure a workplace free from harassment and discrimination.

 

Koster contended that the 4th US Circuit Court of Appeals had wrongly upheld a ruling against Strickland last year. The original case was heard by a Boston-based judge brought in because of potential conflicts within North Carolina, where Strickland had worked.

 

A three-judge panel of the 4th Circuit concluded that, although judiciary employees had "behaved imperfectly" and made "missteps" as Strickland’s complaint moved through the court’s internal employment dispute resolution (EDR) process, the system was not so fundamentally unfair as to violate her constitutional rights.

 

Koster argued that the judiciary could not constitutionally require employees to pursue misconduct complaints through a system that lacked an independent decision-maker, meaningful procedural safeguards and adequate remedies.

 

"The federal judiciary has been aware of sexual harassment occurring within its workplace for decades," he wrote. "Yet despite its expertise in establishing sound processes and procedures, inadequate protection of its employees remains."

 

The Justice Department, which has represented the judiciary throughout the lengthy litigation, argued that the case was not an appropriate vehicle for addressing those broader issues and maintained that Strickland’s claims lacked merit.

 

In a statement, Koster said the Supreme Court’s decision not to hear the appeal was disappointing and called on Congress to intervene.

 

"Employment by the federal judiciary should not mean losing essential protections against workplace discrimination and harassment," he said.

 

The Administrative Office of the US Courts, the judiciary’s administrative arm, did not respond to requests for comment.

 

Strickland was among a group of former female judiciary employees who testified before Congress in 2022 in support of legislation intended to give judicial employees greater workplace protections. Democratic lawmakers continue to pursue the proposal, while also urging the judiciary to do more to prevent workplace misconduct.

 

Strickland worked from 2017 to 2019 at the Federal Public Defender’s Office in the Western District of North Carolina. The office provides legal representation to defendants unable to afford lawyers and is part of the federal judiciary.

 

She filed her lawsuit in 2020, alleging that her constitutional rights had been violated through the mishandling of a complaint against her direct supervisor.

 

Among the evidence she cited was an email dated May 18, 2018, which she described as a "quid pro quo" message. Sent after the two had gone for drinks, it offered to help advance her career and increase her salary. The supervisor said he had a "plan" to raise her pay, adding: "just remember I deal in pay-for-stay :)."

 

Strickland alleged that the district’s then-chief federal defender responded to her complaint with deliberate indifference. She also accused officials of mishandling the complaint she subsequently pursued through the EDR system administered by the 4th Circuit.

 

Following a non-jury trial, US District Judge William Young ruled against Strickland in August 2024. Nevertheless, he endorsed calls for reform, writing that if "judges are serious about sexual harassment, we must own the process".

 

The case is Strickland v. United States, US Supreme Court, No. 25-1303.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

LeBron James Sues Betting App Bron Over Alleged Trademark Infringement

LeBron James Sues Betting App Bron Over Alleged Trademark Infringement

NBA superstar accuses the platform of using his AI-generated likeness in an ad campaign without his permission.

Basketball superstar LeBron James sued the sports betting research app Bron on Tuesday, accusing it of trademark infringement for using his nickname and an artificial intelligence-generated likeness of him in a recent advertising campaign without his permission.

 

In a complaint filed in a federal court in Manhattan, the Philadelphia 76ers forward said he carefully protects his image and exercises control over the brands and businesses he endorses. His status as "one of the most recognisable identities in the world" means he commands tens of millions of dollars for endorsing products and commercial ventures, the complaint said.

 

James' endorsement is "uniquely valuable", the complaint said, adding: "And that is why defendants decided to steal it all for themselves."

 

Bron did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The lawsuit also names the app's co-founders, Anish Gupta and Marc Zoghby, as defendants.

 

James, 41, is the National Basketball Association's all-time leading scorer and has won four Most Valuable Player awards and four league championships. He has also secured three Olympic gold medals.

 

The lawsuit seeks an injunction preventing the defendants from using the Bron name, along with unspecified compensatory and punitive damages.

 

Athletes and celebrities frequently bring legal action to protect their intellectual property and control the commercial use of their names and images. Another NBA star, Miami Heat forward Giannis Antetokounmpo, has filed several lawsuits to protect his "Greek Freak" trademark and challenge the unauthorised use of his name and likeness.

 

AI Version of Himself

 

Bron, also known as PlayVision, is described in Apple's App Store as a sports analytics and betting research application offering live odds comparisons, data-backed picks, player and team trends, multi-leg bet slips and bet tracking. The description states that the platform does not accept wagers.

 

James took issue with a recent Bron advertising campaign which, according to the complaint, featured an AI-generated version of him using his voice, wearing a basketball jersey displaying his Bron nickname and number 23, sporting his tattoos and scrolling through wagers on other NBA players.

 

The complaint said the depiction "falsely communicates that Mr. James wagers, or considers wagering, on NBA games and NBA player performance – conduct that NBA rules prohibit".

 

James said he had been "especially careful in the sports-betting and prediction-market space" and already had an "exclusive endorsement relationship" with prediction markets platform Polymarket.

 

He also accused the defendants of using a cease-and-desist letter sent by his lawyer on November 5 to generate further publicity. Following the letter, the company removed the advertisement and promised users a "new name", without disclosing what the replacement would be, the complaint said.

 

Luka Doncic, another NBA superstar and James' former team-mate at the Los Angeles Lakers, also appeared in the Bron advertisement and sent a cease-and-desist letter, according to the complaint.

 

"Advances in AI have lowered technological barriers and threaten to make this kind of theft and misappropriation commonplace unless the law is followed," the complaint said. "Defendants must face the legal consequences of their intentional conduct to prevent it from being repeated."

 

James is represented by Alex Spiro, whose high-profile clients have included billionaire entrepreneur Elon Musk, rapper and businessman Jay-Z, actor Alec Baldwin and former New York City Mayor Eric Adams.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

Trump Asks USSC To Further Restrict Judges’ Powers Over Federal Agencies

Trump Asks USSC To Further Restrict Judges’ Powers Over Federal Agencies

The administration wants to limit judges’ authority to strike down federal regulations nationwide.

At the US Supreme Court, President Donald Trump is seeking to further restrict the power of federal judges to block his administration’s policies, targeting a judicial tool that remains available despite a major ruling in his favour last year.

 

After persuading the Supreme Court in 2025 to limit federal judges’ ability to block presidential actions nationwide, the administration is now challenging their separate authority to invalidate regulations issued by federal agencies.

 

An appeal filed by the Justice Department and now pending before the Supreme Court urges the justices to curtail the longstanding power of judges to halt the implementation of federal agency rules. Such agencies play a significant role in carrying out the Republican president’s policy priorities.

 

The administration argues that courts should not be able to strike down an agency regulation in its entirety. Instead, any relief granted should be restricted to the specific plaintiffs who brought the case.

 

Aditya Bamzai, an administrative law expert at the University of Virginia, said a ruling in Trump’s favour could allow the government to continue enforcing regulations against everyone except the plaintiffs, potentially for years while legal proceedings continue, even after judges have found the rules unlawful.

 

A decision supporting the administration would give the executive branch greater flexibility, Bamzai said, adding that views on such flexibility could depend on whether people supported or opposed the policies of a particular administration.

 

Since returning to office in January 2025, Trump and his allies have repeatedly criticised judges who have obstructed his policies, describing some as radical or corrupt, as he tests the limits of presidential authority.

 

At the administration’s request, the Supreme Court in June 2025 restricted the use of nationwide, or universal, injunctions. Such orders can prevent the government from enforcing a policy against anyone, rather than only those who have brought a legal challenge.

 

Federal judges had increasingly used these injunctions in a range of cases against the Trump administration, including challenges alleging violations of the US Constitution.

 

The latest appeal stems from a legal challenge brought by healthcare providers in Texas against federal regulations implementing legislation signed by Trump during his first term. The legislation was intended to protect patients from unexpected medical bills.

 

The appeal forms part of a wider administration effort to make it more difficult for courts to obstruct executive actions. The Supreme Court is expected to consider whether to hear the case early next year.

 

The disputes targeted by the administration involve the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), a 1946 federal law governing the operations of government agencies, including the process through which they introduce and implement regulations.

 

Judges and appellate courts have traditionally interpreted the statute as giving them the authority to ‘hold unlawful and set aside’ agency regulations they find illegal, effectively invalidating such rules nationwide.

 

Since Trump returned to the White House, his administration has faced hundreds of lawsuits challenging measures involving immigration restrictions, mass deportations, the termination of diversity initiatives and limits on transgender rights, among other policies that have raised questions about the scope of presidential power.

 

The APA has been invoked in numerous cases, including challenges to the termination of humanitarian legal status for hundreds of thousands of migrants living in the US, substantial reductions in research grants involving racial minorities and LGBT people, and the introduction of a mass voter verification system to conduct extensive citizenship checks.

 

Executive Overreach

 

Supporters of the existing judicial power, including several state governments that regularly challenge federal policies, argue that it is an essential safeguard against executive overreach. Others maintain that the APA is necessary to ensure regulations are applied consistently rather than differently to individual parties.

 

When an agency introduces a regulation that is subsequently found unlawful, removing it entirely may be the only practical solution, said Ronald Levin, a law professor at Washington University in St Louis.

 

He cited food safety and vehicle manufacturing standards as examples of regulations that cannot sensibly apply to some businesses while excluding others. Although judges should not exercise the power in every case, there are circumstances in which nationwide relief is necessary, he said.

 

The Supreme Court’s 2025 decision restricting nationwide injunctions arose from litigation over Trump’s attempt to limit birthright citizenship, a right long recognised in the US. That ruling dealt with the powers of federal judges rather than the legality of the president’s directive.

 

Former Democratic President Joe Biden’s administration had also asked the Supreme Court to restrict the use of universal injunctions after lower courts blocked several of its major initiatives. Nevertheless, the 2025 decision represented a significant victory for Trump.

 

In a separate 6-3 ruling in June 2025, the justices subsequently rejected Trump’s birthright citizenship policy as unconstitutional.

 

Dispute Over Surprise Medical Bills

 

The Trump administration is now seeking to extend the restrictions imposed by the 2025 ruling to similar judicial orders issued under the APA to invalidate government policies.

 

The regulation at the centre of the latest case was designed to limit unexpected medical bills charged by hospitals and healthcare providers outside a patient’s health insurance network.

 

A Texas association of medical doctors, air ambulance providers and other plaintiffs challenged the regulation, arguing that it violated the APA and artificially reduced their insurance reimbursement rates.

 

In August, the New Orleans-based 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals invalidated parts of the regulation nationwide, finding that they violated the APA.

 

The Trump administration’s appeal does not challenge the appeals court’s conclusion on the legality of the regulation. Instead, it seeks to prevent courts from using the APA to invalidate government policies on a nationwide basis.

 

The administration argues, as it did in the earlier dispute over universal injunctions, that the APA does not give courts such broad powers. It says judges should be able to restrict enforcement of a regulation only against the specific parties who challenged it.

 

The Justice Department said in its filing that the Supreme Court should restore lower courts to what it considers their proper role under the APA.

 

If the justices agree, it would take longer for challengers to have regulations declared unlawful and removed from the statute books, Levin said.

 

The Biden administration also sought to persuade the Supreme Court in 2023 to restrict judges’ use of this power in a case brought by Republican attorneys general from Texas and Louisiana challenging an immigration policy. The justices declined to address the issue and ruled in Biden’s favour on other grounds.

 

Trump’s latest initiative, however, could face opposition from an unusually broad group of states.

 

Texas, Florida and several other states, most of them Republican-led, had urged the 5th Circuit not to weaken the effectiveness of the APA. They argued that the legislation was an important safeguard for maintaining the balance of power between state governments and the federal administration.

 

The states described the APA as a critical instrument for checking federal overreach and protecting state sovereignty against actions by executive-branch agencies.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

NetChoice Challenges New York Law Requiring Social Media Warning Labels

NetChoice Challenges New York Law Requiring Social Media Warning Labels

The internet trade group argues that mandatory warnings on platforms with potentially addictive features violate constitutional free speech protections.

NetChoice, an internet trade group, has sued New York, seeking to block a state law requiring social media platforms with potentially addictive features to display state-approved warning labels to users.

 

In a complaint filed in federal court, NetChoice argued that the law violates the free speech protections guaranteed by the First Amendment to the US Constitution, as it compels its members to communicate the state's preferred message about online safety.

 

The office of New York Attorney General Letitia James, responsible for enforcing the state's laws, declined to comment immediately.

 

NetChoice has more than 30 members, including Alphabet's Google and YouTube, Meta Platforms, which owns Facebook and Instagram, Snap, the parent company of Snapchat, and ByteDance's TikTok. The organisation has filed numerous lawsuits challenging regulations affecting social media businesses.

 

Signed by Governor Kathy Hochul last December, the New York law requires social media platforms featuring infinite scrolling, auto-play and algorithm-driven feeds to display warnings about potential harm to younger users.

 

The legislation requires platforms to show a warning based on a statement by the US Surgeon General, which says that although social media may benefit some young users, "excessive use may be associated with significant mental health harms".

 

The warning is modelled on findings published in 2023 by former US Surgeon General Vivek Murthy.

 

NetChoice argued that the law was designed to restrict and discourage social media use by repeatedly exposing users to the warning when they log in and after spending several hours on a platform, without giving them an option to bypass it.

 

Unlike a static warning printed on a product label, the group said, the repeated notices interrupt users and prevent them from accessing content protected by the First Amendment.

 

NetChoice filed a similar lawsuit against California last month.

 

The group also contended that New York's legislation resembles a Colorado law that was blocked by a federal judge in November 2025 on First Amendment grounds. Colorado is appealing against that ruling.

 

New York's law is scheduled to come into effect on January 1.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

Excessive Reliance On Arbitration Could Stifle Growth of Law: Ex-India SC Judge

Excessive Reliance On Arbitration Could Stifle Growth of Law: Ex-India SC Judge

Justice Ravindra Bhat says limited judicial review of arbitral awards raises questions about how legal principles will evolve.

Former Supreme Court Justice S. Ravindra Bhat has cautioned that referring all disputes to arbitration could eventually slow the development of law, while acknowledging that Indian courts have significantly reduced their intervention in arbitral awards over the past decade.

 

Speaking at Dubai Arbitration Week 2026, Justice Bhat said legal principles had traditionally developed through rigorous judicial examination. The increasingly limited scope for reviewing arbitral awards, he suggested, raised questions about how new legal concepts would emerge and evolve.

 

“If you leave everything to arbitration, as we all believe that all disputes should be arbitrable, I think there will be a time when the growth of law will be static,” he said.

 

Justice Bhat was speaking at a panel discussion titled “Four Courts, One Award: Judicial Perspectives, Cross-Border Advocacy & the Great Common Law Debate”, organised by the Indian Institute of Arbitration and Mediation. The panel also featured former Abu Dhabi Courts judge Ahmed Bakry.

 

Justice Bhat clarified that he was not proposing a radical shift in the approach to arbitration. However, he said developments in technology and emerging questions surrounding damages and other legal doctrines called for consideration of the role courts should play in shaping the law.

 

He observed that judicial scrutiny had historically contributed to the development of legal principles. If disputes were increasingly resolved through arbitration, with only limited opportunities for court intervention, the evolution of new doctrines could become more difficult.

 

An arbitral award could withstand judicial scrutiny as long as it satisfied the internationally recognised threshold of public policy. This, he said, raised a wider question about how the law would continue to develop as arbitration became the preferred mechanism for resolving disputes.

 

On India's approach to judicial intervention, Justice Bhat said the position had undergone a considerable change over the past decade. The Supreme Court had repeatedly stressed that interference with arbitral awards should remain minimal and that public policy could not be invoked to accommodate every objection raised against an award.

 

“But the courts are more constrained now in the sense that unless something is egregious and it appears on the face of the award, the enquiry doesn't proceed further,” he said.

 

He also warned against drawing direct comparisons between India and Singapore, pointing to differences in the scale of India's judicial system, interpretations of public policy and the increasing pressure on commercial courts. Nevertheless, he acknowledged that the interpretation of public policy had become more consistent over the past decade.

 

Former Abu Dhabi Courts judge Bakry said courts seeking to promote arbitration must strike a balance between restraint and effective judicial supervision. They should ensure that parties had genuinely agreed to arbitrate, while recognising that judicial specialisation required more than simply establishing dedicated courts.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

Trump’s $10 Billion BBC Defamation Suit Cleared To Proceed By US Judge

Trump’s $10 Billion BBC Defamation Suit Cleared To Proceed By US Judge

Court allows Trump’s claim over an edited speech to move forward but dismisses his unfair trade practices allegation.

A federal judge has ruled that US President Donald Trump’s $10 billion defamation lawsuit against the BBC over a misleadingly edited clip of a speech can proceed, but dismissed his claim of unfair trade practices against the broadcaster.

 

Trump is suing Britain’s publicly funded broadcaster for at least $10 billion over edited clips of a speech that made it appear he had directed supporters to storm the US Capitol on January 6, 2021. The case is one of several lawsuits Trump has filed against news organisations as part of a wider campaign to challenge media coverage he dislikes.

 

US District Judge Jeffrey Kuntz in Florida declined to dismiss Trump’s defamation claim, ruling that he had plausibly alleged that the broadcaster had damaged his reputation and knew, or should have known, that the edited clip was misleading. However, the ruling did not determine whether Trump had established those allegations.

 

Trump described the decision as a “huge victory” in a social media post. “We will continue fighting against, and defeating, all of those who try to deceive the American People!” he wrote.

 

A BBC spokesperson said the broadcaster was surprised by the decision but respected the court’s authority and remained confident in its position.

 

The BBC has previously acknowledged that the edits were misleading and apologised to Trump, although it denies being legally liable for defamation.

 

Trump’s lawsuit, filed in December in a Florida federal court, accuses the BBC of defaming him by splicing together separate sections of his speech. These included a passage in which he told supporters to march on the Capitol and another in which he urged them to “fight like hell”. The edited version omitted a section in which he called for peaceful protest.

 

The speech was featured in a BBC Panorama documentary shortly before the 2024 presidential election, which Trump won. A leaked internal BBC memo subsequently cited the edits as evidence of potential political bias, triggering a public relations crisis for the broadcaster and leading to several high-level resignations.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.

Google Sued Over Claims Gemini Chat Helped US Student Plan Suicide Attempt

Google Sued Over Claims Gemini Chat Helped US Student Plan Suicide Attempt

Parents allege Google failed to warn schools and families about risks associated with its AI chatbot.

The parents of a US schoolgirl have sued Google, alleging that its Gemini artificial intelligence chatbot helped their daughter plan a suicide attempt after she accessed the service through a school-provided Chromebook.

 

The lawsuit claims that Google expanded the availability of its AI products among students without adequately informing parents and schools about the potential risks. The girl, identified in the proceedings as Emma, began using Gemini on her school laptop when she was 13.

 

According to the complaint, Emma discussed different methods of suicide with the chatbot and made plans for her own funeral. The lawsuit further alleges that the AI tool helped her conceal her emotional struggles from her family.

 

Her parents reportedly became aware of the situation after school monitoring software flagged a document she had prepared containing details of her funeral arrangements.

 

The complaint alleges that Google prioritised expanding Gemini's user base by integrating the technology across its products without providing sufficient warnings to parents or educational institutions. It also claims that the company knew the Gemini 3 Flash model, which Emma used, had safety shortcomings in dealing with users experiencing mental health difficulties.

 

A Google spokesperson said the company was reviewing the allegations. The company said it had worked extensively with medical professionals and academic experts to develop features that direct young people towards appropriate support and reliable resources when needed.

 

The lawsuit, which seeks monetary damages, was initially filed in a California state court on Monday before Google transferred the proceedings to a federal court on Wednesday.

 

The legal action comes as Google moves to change how its AI services are made available to students. The company said it would disable Gemini by default for school student accounts. However, schools wishing to retain access to Google Search will still have to accept certain AI-powered features, including automatically generated summaries.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.