A federal judge in Washington has ordered President Donald Trump’s administration to produce records sought by the American Bar Association (ABA) in its lawsuit alleging that the White House unlawfully targeted law firms over their previous legal work, diversity policies and political affiliations.
The ruling by US District Judge Amir Ali, directs the White House to disclose its communications with law firms targeted by Trump through executive orders, as well as correspondence with firms that subsequently reached agreements with the administration and records relating to those arrangements.
The ABA sued the administration last year, alleging that the White House had adopted an unlawful policy of retaliating against law firms and lawyers because of their speech and legal representations that the government opposed. The organisation, which represents attorneys across the United States, sought the records as evidence in support of its claims.
Ali rejected the association’s request for access to certain records for the time being, but said it could submit further arguments seeking their disclosure. The judge said he was carefully balancing the ABA’s need for evidence against the White House’s interest in protecting the confidentiality of its communications.
The White House had challenged the scope of the ABA’s demands, describing them as excessively broad and arguing that responding to the requests would disrupt the functioning of the executive branch.
Lauren Bis, a White House spokesperson, criticised the ruling in a statement on Monday, describing the judge as an “activist judge” seeking to compel the disclosure of protected internal communications. She added that the administration was confident the decision would not be the final word in the case.
Trump issued executive orders last year targeting several prominent law firms. The measures sought to revoke lawyers’ security clearances, restrict their access to federal buildings and threaten the termination of US government contracts held by their clients.
Nine major firms subsequently reached agreements with the White House to rescind or avoid such orders, pledging nearly $1 billion in pro bono legal services for causes supported by the administration.
The ABA’s lawsuit, brought by the largest attorney membership organisation in the United States, seeks a declaration that the administration’s alleged policy of targeting law firms violates the US Constitution. It also asks the court to prevent the White House and federal agencies from enforcing the policy.
In his latest ruling, Ali said draft versions of the executive orders could provide important evidence about the administration’s intentions.
“Drafts of the law firm orders will reveal how the language in those orders changed over time, which may shed light on the government’s motivation in issuing the orders and the desired effect of the orders on the law firms,” he wrote.
The White House has invoked presidential communications privilege to withhold the names of individual administration officials who possess information about the executive orders targeting law firms. Ali has yet to determine whether the administration’s claim to that privilege is valid.
Four judges struck down executive orders targeting law firms last year, ruling that the measures violated the firms’ constitutional rights to free speech and due process. The Trump administration is appealing those decisions.
The case is American Bar Association v. Executive Office of the President, US District Court for the District of Columbia, No. 1:25-cv-01888-AHA.
For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.
