The Abu Dhabi Commercial Court of First Instance has ordered the Abu Dhabi branch of a foreign marine services company to pay $49,359.60 to a marine supplier, rejecting the buyer's attempt to avoid part of the outstanding debt by invoking a contractual clause allowing cancellation for late delivery.
In a judgment dated November 11, 2026, the court ordered payment of the full claimed amount, or its equivalent in UAE dirhams at the date of payment, together with annual interest of 3% from the date the claim was filed until settlement, subject to a cap of the principal amount. The buyer was also ordered to pay court costs.
The dispute arose from six purchase orders issued between February and March 2024 for marine supplies intended for a vessel. The orders covered batteries, lubricants, paints, silica gel, grease and insulated ladders, with delivery scheduled in Pointe Noire, Congo. Payment was due within 30 days of invoicing.
The supplier delivered the goods, and the buyer's representatives signed and stamped the delivery documents. However, payment remained outstanding. A statement of account issued in April 2025 showed an unpaid balance of $49,359.60, prompting the supplier to initiate legal proceedings on October 28, 2026.
The buyer acknowledged the commercial relationship and deliveries but disputed part of the claim. It accepted that approximately $8,444 relating to three invoices remained unpaid, while arguing that late delivery under two other purchase orders entitled it to cancel those orders and avoid the corresponding payments.
The court examined the purchase orders, tax invoices, signed delivery notes, email correspondence and statement of account. It accepted the documentary evidence, relying on Article 34 of the Commercial Transactions Law and relevant Abu Dhabi Court of Cassation principles concerning commercial records and electronic evidence.
The court held that properly maintained electronic accounting records could carry the same evidential weight as regular commercial books. Such records would bind the opposing merchant unless rebutted through its own regular books or other admissible evidence. The buyer had failed to provide such a rebuttal. The court also recognised the evidential value of electronic correspondence and treated admissions in the buyer's written response as binding judicial admissions.
A decisive issue was whether the buyer had exercised its contractual cancellation rights in accordance with the agreed purchase terms. The contract provided for liquidated damages of 1% of the order value for each full week of delay, subject to a maximum of 10%. It also allowed termination without liability if delivery was delayed by more than five weeks. A separate provision permitted cancellation if the supplier failed to remedy a breach within seven days of receiving notice.
The court found that the buyer had not established a valid basis for cancellation under either provision. In relation to the first disputed order, the delay had not exceeded five weeks. In the second instance, although the delay exceeded that period, the buyer had failed to issue notice within the contractual timeframe.
The supplier had informed the buyer by email on April 18, 2024, apologising for the delay and promising delivery the following day. The buyer subsequently confirmed shipment by sea to Abu Dhabi on April 25, received the goods on April 26, and issued its cancellation notice only on April 27. The court found that the cancellation had not been exercised in accordance with the contractual requirements.
It concluded that the buyer could not rely on the cancellation provisions to avoid payment. Its remedy was limited to claiming the agreed liquidated damages, provided these were properly claimed and established. As no such claim had been proved, the defence was rejected.
The court awarded interest at 3% annually from October 28, 2026, the date of filing, until full payment, subject to the principal amount. It declined the supplier's request for 5% interest calculated from April 28, 2024, finding that the parties had not agreed on an interest rate. The contractual 30-day payment period established the due date but did not, by itself, determine the applicable interest rate.
The litigation was led by UAE-based legal consultancy Kaden Boriss, represented by its local counsel Ayesha Al Zaabi, which pursued recovery of the outstanding amount through documentary evidence and contractual interpretation.
The judgment highlights the importance of maintaining proper commercial records, including purchase orders, invoices, delivery confirmations and statements of account. It also reinforces the principle that contractual cancellation rights must be exercised strictly in accordance with agreed notice periods and conditions.
Abu Dhabi court awards $49,359.60 to a marine supplier after rejecting a buyer's late-delivery cancellation defence over unpaid vessel supplies and invoices.
For businesses engaged in cross-border commercial transactions, the ruling underlines the value of clear contractual provisions, documented communications and timely enforcement of payment obligations. It also demonstrates how a party's own correspondence and subsequent conduct may become significant evidence when the validity of a contractual defence is examined.
For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.
