The Ajman Federal Court of Appeal has overturned a Court of First Instance judgment and ordered two respondents to jointly pay Dh735,188.32 in a commercial financial dispute, together with 5% legal interest until full payment, legal fees and litigation expenses.
The dispute arose from a commercial arrangement under which an individual advanced funds to finance purchase orders and facilitate services for hotels and other companies. Despite an agreement to repay the money within the stipulated period, the amount remained outstanding, raising questions over the authenticity of the supporting purchase orders and the use of the funds. The failure to recover the money resulted in a substantial financial claim and subsequent legal proceedings.
The claimant initiated civil proceedings seeking recovery of the outstanding amount. However, the Court of First Instance dismissed the claim on the grounds that it was premature. The decision was subsequently challenged before the Ajman Federal Court of Appeal, where the appeal focused on establishing the financial transactions, the nature of the funds advanced and the respondents' liability for repayment.
A central element of the appeal was an independent accounting expert's examination of the financial records and supporting documents. The expert confirmed that Dh630,866 had been transferred to the company's bank account and identified signed acknowledgments corresponding to the claimed amount of Dh735,188.32. The examination also found that the purchase orders under review did not belong to the entities to which they had been attributed.
The bank transfer records, written acknowledgments and expert findings were presented before the Court of Appeal to establish the movement of funds and substantiate the repayment claim. The evidence also addressed the distinction between the personal funds advanced and any amounts associated with the company's share capital.
In its judgment dated September 29, 2026, the Ajman Federal Court of Appeal accepted the appeal, overturned the lower court's decision and ruled in favour of the claimant. It ordered the respondents to jointly pay Dh735,188.32, together with 5% legal interest calculated from the date of filing the claim until full payment.
The court also awarded Dh10,000 in legal fees covering both levels of litigation and ordered payment of the applicable court expenses. It further recognised that the amount claimed represented personal funds advanced for the commercial arrangement rather than a contribution to the company's share capital.
The litigation was led by UAE-based legal consultancy Kaden Boriss, represented by its local counsel Ayesha Al Zaabi. The legal proceedings focused on establishing the financial liability through documentary evidence, transaction records and independent expert assessment.
The judgment highlights the importance of maintaining reliable financial records and obtaining independent expert assessments in commercial disputes involving advances, purchase orders and repayment obligations. It also demonstrates the role of appellate proceedings in reconsidering claims where documentary and expert evidence may establish financial liability that was not recognised at the first-instance stage.
For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.
