Dubai Court Upholds Businessman’s Acquittal In Alleged Detention Case

Dubai Court Upholds Businessman’s Acquittal In Alleged Detention Case

Disputed witness accounts and telephone records led the court to find insufficient grounds to overturn the acquittal.

AuthorStaff WriterNov 19, 2026, 10:45 AM

The Dubai Court of Appeal has upheld the acquittal of a businessman accused of detaining a woman in his Business Bay apartment for around six hours and allegedly using force and threats to compel her to engage in sexual activity.

 

The court dismissed the Public Prosecution’s appeal, finding insufficient evidence to overturn the Court of First Instance’s verdict. The businessman had faced charges of unlawfully depriving the woman of her freedom through force and threats for a sexual purpose under the UAE Crimes and Penalties Law.

 

According to prosecution records, the woman told investigators that she had met the businessman near a nightclub and accepted his invitation to visit his apartment for drinks. She alleged that he pressured her to consume alcohol and refused to let her leave when she asked to go.

 

She further claimed that he raised a shoe towards her face in a threatening manner, grabbed her and pushed her onto a sofa in the bedroom. When she attempted to contact a friend, he allegedly took her phone temporarily.

 

The woman said she eventually managed to message her friend and share her live location when a delivery driver arrived. Her friend subsequently went to the building seeking assistance, leading to police intervention.

 

The businessman denied the allegations, maintaining that the woman had visited voluntarily and that he had neither restrained nor assaulted her.

 

Security Guard’s Testimony

 

A building security guard told the court that the woman had entered the premises voluntarily and that her visitor details had been recorded in the reception system.

 

The guard said he accompanied police officers to the apartment, where the businessman opened the door. He found the woman standing in the living room holding her phone. She appeared normal and began crying only after officers spoke to her, according to his testimony.

 

The Court of First Instance considered the guard’s account alongside the building records when assessing whether unlawful confinement had been established. It questioned whether the allegation of a six-hour detention was consistent with the guard’s description of finding the woman standing with her phone.

 

The arresting officer testified that the businessman initially denied having a woman inside the apartment, but police subsequently found her there. The officer also said the businessman had referred to a financial disagreement.

 

Another officer, who had not attended the scene, told the court that he had recorded the woman’s statement at the police station. As she spoke in her native language, her friend translated her account into English.

 

The Court of First Instance disregarded statements attributed to the businessman in an initial police report because he had been questioned without the assistance of a sworn interpreter.

 

The defence also argued that the complainant and her friend had not appeared for cross-examination, leaving their accounts untested under oath.

 

Phone Records and Messages Form Part of defence

 

The defence examined the case file, reconstructed the sequence of events and analysed telephone records and WhatsApp messages.

 

It argued that the communications demonstrated prior contact and arrangements involving the businessman and another woman, whom the defence alleged had helped shape the accusation. According to its account, this woman had arranged for the complainant to meet the businessman voluntarily, contradicting the allegation that he had lured or detained her.

 

The defence also relied on a telephone call between the businessman and his wife that allegedly lasted more than an hour during the period in which the complainant claimed she was being detained and threatened. It argued that the call raised questions about the complainant’s version of events.

 

Images of the apartment entrance were also presented to show that the door could be opened from inside without a key. The defence maintained that the woman had retained her smartphone and could communicate, with no apparent obstacle preventing her from leaving or seeking assistance. Defence witnesses also supported its position.

 

The defence further highlighted discrepancies between the prosecution witnesses’ courtroom testimony and their earlier statements to the Public Prosecution.

 

Appeal Court Finds No Grounds to Interfere

 

The Court of First Instance acquitted the businessman, concluding that the evidence was insufficient to establish the alleged offences, particularly the required criminal intent.

 

The Public Prosecution challenged the acquittal, but the Court of Appeal found no sufficient legal or evidential grounds to disturb the lower court’s findings. It accordingly rejected the appeal and upheld the businessman’s acquittal.

 

For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.