Dubai Civil Court has ordered a man to repay Dh7.4 million misappropriated from a company and pay a further Dh500,000 in compensation for the financial losses it suffered after he was convicted of forging an electronic customs declaration to facilitate a fictitious computer server import transaction.
However, the court rejected the company's claim against a business owned by the defendant, ruling that there was no evidence that the misappropriated funds had entered the company's accounts or assets.
The lawsuit was initially filed by the affected company, which sought a joint order against the man and his company to recover Dh7.4 million and pay Dh1 million in compensation for material losses and lost profits.
The company alleged that it had been deceived by documents falsely representing the existence of a transaction involving the import of computer servers. According to its claim, the defendant produced a forged customs declaration purportedly issued by Dubai Customs to make the transaction appear genuine.
Relying on the documents, the company transferred $2.04 million, equivalent to Dh7.4 million, through three separate bank transactions.
The criminal proceedings had earlier resulted in the man being sentenced to one year in prison, followed by deportation. He was also fined Dh150,000, in addition to a further Dhs7.4 million penalty corresponding to the funds involved in the offence. The court ordered the deletion of the forged electronic data. The Court of Appeal upheld the ruling, making the conviction final.
Arbitration Defence Rejected
The defendants argued that the civil claim was inadmissible because the contract contained an arbitration clause. The court dismissed the objection, holding that the company's claim arose from tortious liability for a wrongful act rather than a contractual dispute concerning the performance or termination of the agreement.
The court found that the documents established that the money had been transferred to a company's bank account in an Asian country. It also relied on the final criminal judgment, which had established that the first defendant misappropriated the funds, making him personally liable to return the amount.
Compensation for Financial Losses
In assessing the company's compensation claim, the court found that it had suffered material harm by being deprived of the use of its money and losing potential investment opportunities.
It fixed compensation at Dh500,000, rather than the Dh1 million sought by the company.
The court separately examined the liability of the second defendant, the company owned by the man. It held that the company had a legal personality and financial estate independent of those of its partner. As there was no evidence that the disputed funds had become part of its assets, the court found no basis for making it jointly liable for repayment or compensation.
The court ordered the first defendant to pay the legal costs, court expenses and lawyer's fees, while dismissing the remaining claims.
For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.
