The US Supreme Court declined to hear a case challenging how the federal judiciary handles complaints of employee misconduct, rejecting an appeal by a former federal public defender who alleged that she had been sexually harassed by her supervisor.
The justices declined to hear Caryn Strickland’s appeal against a lower court ruling that found she had failed to establish violations of her Fifth Amendment rights under the US Constitution, including equal protection under the law and due process.
Her case had been the subject of a rare trial examining how the judiciary handles workplace misconduct complaints involving its 30,000 employees. Unlike other federal government workers, judicial employees are not covered by statutory protections against discrimination.
In a petition urging the Supreme Court to take up the case, Strickland’s lawyer, Emory University law professor Paul Koster, argued that it offered the justices an opportunity to clarify the federal judiciary’s responsibility to ensure a workplace free from harassment and discrimination.
Koster contended that the 4th US Circuit Court of Appeals had wrongly upheld a ruling against Strickland last year. The original case was heard by a Boston-based judge brought in because of potential conflicts within North Carolina, where Strickland had worked.
A three-judge panel of the 4th Circuit concluded that, although judiciary employees had "behaved imperfectly" and made "missteps" as Strickland’s complaint moved through the court’s internal employment dispute resolution (EDR) process, the system was not so fundamentally unfair as to violate her constitutional rights.
Koster argued that the judiciary could not constitutionally require employees to pursue misconduct complaints through a system that lacked an independent decision-maker, meaningful procedural safeguards and adequate remedies.
"The federal judiciary has been aware of sexual harassment occurring within its workplace for decades," he wrote. "Yet despite its expertise in establishing sound processes and procedures, inadequate protection of its employees remains."
The Justice Department, which has represented the judiciary throughout the lengthy litigation, argued that the case was not an appropriate vehicle for addressing those broader issues and maintained that Strickland’s claims lacked merit.
In a statement, Koster said the Supreme Court’s decision not to hear the appeal was disappointing and called on Congress to intervene.
"Employment by the federal judiciary should not mean losing essential protections against workplace discrimination and harassment," he said.
The Administrative Office of the US Courts, the judiciary’s administrative arm, did not respond to requests for comment.
Strickland was among a group of former female judiciary employees who testified before Congress in 2022 in support of legislation intended to give judicial employees greater workplace protections. Democratic lawmakers continue to pursue the proposal, while also urging the judiciary to do more to prevent workplace misconduct.
Strickland worked from 2017 to 2019 at the Federal Public Defender’s Office in the Western District of North Carolina. The office provides legal representation to defendants unable to afford lawyers and is part of the federal judiciary.
She filed her lawsuit in 2020, alleging that her constitutional rights had been violated through the mishandling of a complaint against her direct supervisor.
Among the evidence she cited was an email dated May 18, 2018, which she described as a "quid pro quo" message. Sent after the two had gone for drinks, it offered to help advance her career and increase her salary. The supervisor said he had a "plan" to raise her pay, adding: "just remember I deal in pay-for-stay :)."
Strickland alleged that the district’s then-chief federal defender responded to her complaint with deliberate indifference. She also accused officials of mishandling the complaint she subsequently pursued through the EDR system administered by the 4th Circuit.
Following a non-jury trial, US District Judge William Young ruled against Strickland in August 2024. Nevertheless, he endorsed calls for reform, writing that if "judges are serious about sexual harassment, we must own the process".
The case is Strickland v. United States, US Supreme Court, No. 25-1303.
For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.
