Ford, Honda, Stellantis subsidiary FCA and Volkswagen have sued the state of New Jersey in an attempt to block a new law that they say significantly increases the amounts automakers must pay franchised dealers for warranty and recall repairs.
In a complaint filed in federal court in Trenton, New Jersey, on Friday, the automakers argued that the New Jersey Motor Vehicle Open Recall Notice and Fair Compensation Act gives dealers a “blank cheque” to set prices for warranty, recall and other repair services, while preventing manufacturers from avoiding what they describe as “extortionate” charges or recovering the additional costs.
The legislation could transfer more than $375 million annually from automakers to dealers, giving the latter a financial “windfall” without requiring them to use the additional revenue to improve customer service or increase employee compensation, the companies said.
“In short, the act rewards dealers for charging their customers more,” the automakers said in the complaint.
The office of New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport, responsible for enforcing the state's laws, declined to comment.
The legislation came into effect on April 1, following its signing by former Governor Phil Murphy in September 2025.
Constitutional Violations Alleged
The automakers challenged a provision allowing dealers to apply a “labour multiplier” based on samples of repair orders, arguing that it enables them to bill manufacturers for substantially more labour time than technicians actually spend carrying out the work.
They also objected to provisions requiring manufacturers to pay marked-up prices for parts that dealers may have obtained at discounted rates or free of charge. Another provision prevents automakers from supplying less expensive parts, even when market conditions, supply and demand or other factors justify lower prices, they said.
Ford, Honda, FCA, which includes Fiat and Chrysler, and Volkswagen said that since the law took effect, each company had received dozens of invoices demanding payment “for hours that no technician works, that surpass what comparable dealers charge for the same work, and that exceed what retail customers pay”.
The companies argued that the legislation violates the US Constitution's Commerce Clause and Takings Clause, is overridden by federal law governing vehicle recalls and also breaches the New Jersey Constitution.
The New Jersey Coalition of Automotive Retailers, a non-profit advocacy organisation, is also named as a defendant.
Its president, Laura Perrotta, said she was confident the organisation would prevail. She accused automakers of having benefited for decades from substantial discounts on parts and labour at dealers' expense.
She also argued that dealers competing for customers should not be expected to pass the costs of warranty and recall repairs on to consumers, describing such an approach as “not an option”.
For enquiries or further information, contact ask@tlr.ae or call +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels.
