Privacy campaigners have raised alarms about the risk of voters' personal data being used for targeted political messaging under new proposed data protection laws. The Open Rights Group and other advocacy organizations have expressed concerns that the bill, introduced in late 2024, could lead to governmental misuse of personal data in political campaigns, granting excessive powers to the Secretary of State without adequate parliamentary scrutiny.

Potential for Abuse in Political Campaigns

The draft data protection legislation grants the Secretary of State the discretion to determine how personal data can be used for political campaigning. This provision, critics argue, could potentially allow the ruling party to exploit voter data in ways that give them an electoral advantage. The bill would also bypass the existing risk assessment process that currently ensures that individuals' data rights are balanced with organizational interests.

The new law would allow changes to be made to the rules surrounding data access without the same level of oversight from Parliament as is required for other legislation. Campaigners have compared this power to "Henry VIII powers", referring to the historical ability of the monarch to make laws with minimal parliamentary involvement.

 

Safeguards and Government's Position

Despite the concerns raised, a spokesperson for the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology emphasized that the bill does not directly address the use of personal data for political campaigning. They pointed out that the data bill includes three key safeguards: consultation with the Information Commissioner’s Officer, approval by the UK Parliament, and the requirement that any changes must serve general public interest.

However, some legal experts like Ross McKenzie, a partner at Addleshaw Goddard, noted that while future secretaries of state would not have "completely unfettered" rights to use data, there are still concerns about flexibility that could make it easier for governments to bypass regulations.

 

Broader Implications for Democracy

The Open Rights Group argues that the bill could weaken parliamentary scrutiny, especially amid the rise of populist governments that may be inclined to use executive powers for political advantage. James Baker, a program manager at the Open Rights Group, emphasized the importance of ensuring that political parties have clear and fair rules for using personal data and that these rules should be scrutinized by Parliament to protect the integrity of democracy.

 

Economic Impact and Concerns

The UK government argues that the data bill will cut regulatory red tape and potentially add £10bn to the economy over 10 years. While this goal is seen as beneficial for businesses, there are concerns from human rights perspectives regarding the broader impact on privacy and personal freedoms.

 

Conclusion: A Call for Stronger Oversight

Despite the government's reassurances, the potential for abuses of power remains a significant concern. Critics argue that without stronger safeguards and parliamentary oversight, this bill could pave the way for the misuse of personal data in political campaigns and undermine privacy protections in the UK.

 

 

For any enquiries or information, contact info@thelawreporters.com or call us on +971 52 644 3004. Follow The Law Reporters on WhatsApp Channels